Fasting Not Required
December 22, 2021
Seventy years elapsed between the destruction of Israel's first temple (in 586 B.C.) and the dedication of the second (in 516). During that period, the Israelite survivors kept an annual fast to remember their status as exiles and mourn that which had been lost, including brethren, country, and—most of all—God's temple.

After the events mentioned in "The Burning Bulwark", when the rebuilding of Jerusalem and the temple were well underway, Israel's leaders asked the Lord, "Should we continue our annual fast?" Since the things they had been fasting and mourning were ostensibly returned, they assumed that the fast was no longer necessary. Indeed, Jerusalem had been rebuilt, and also God's house within it.
The Lord responded through Zechariah: "When you kept that fast, was it really for my sake?" Instead of providing a simple "yes" or "no", God returned an introspective question and then followed it with this command: Be just, be kind, and be merciful to one another; furthermore, don't oppress the downtrodden, the helpless, the unfortunate, or anyone else, and don't plan evil things against them.
God's reply was not to sidestep a definitive answer, but to express dutiful anger. While Israel's powerbrokers had ceremoniously observed the fast-of-mourning, they had also opportunistically maltreated their countrymen. "Was it for me that you were fasting?" God asked, "Or for yourselves?" The Lord effectively expressed, By not eating, you had extra time and money, but did you do my good works with them, or did you put that excess toward taking advantage of the least among you? Fast if you wish… or don't, for the important things are these: administer true justice, show kindness, and have mercy on those around you.

The same sentiment is expressed throughout the Bible, perhaps most succinctly in 1 Samuel 15:22: "Does the Lord delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, or in obedience of his word? To obey is better than sacrifices; to heed is better than the fat of rams." Jesus echoed the same belief after religious authorities lambasted his followers and him for picking grain on the Sabbath; he told them, "If you had understood the meaning behind God's saying, 'I desire mercy, not sacrifices', then you would not call us 'guilty'." (Matthew 12:1-8)
Like putting the cart before the horse, who among us is so close to godly perfection that only minutia and details remain? Is the punctuation of our prayers more important than their content? Does religious ceremony take precedence over compassion and decency? Indeed, what good is a fast if we mistreat those around us and abuse the authority God has entrusted to us? We can ask God about the nitty-gritty, but God's priorities are usually elsewhere, like when the prophet Micah explained, "People, the Lord has told you what is good and what is required of you: Do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with your God."
Symmetry
























